Single-Asset Allocation Strategy
Bridesmaid Track Record
Overall, five of the seven assets available for the Bridesmaid strategy have underperformed the S&P 500 over the long-term, and three (Treasury Bonds, Gold, and Commodities) lagged by 390 basis points or more per year.
Momentum: Not Just For Stock Pickers
For those not blessed with clairvoyance, we’ve developed an asset selection strategy that’s done very well, historically, compared to the “naïve” AANA Portfolio and even against the almighty S&P 500. We’re not implying that investors dump their valuation models, economic forecasts, or their intuition. But they should recognize that price momentum tends to persist—not just among stocks and industry groups—but at the asset-class level as well.
Rewarding “Perfect Foresight”
Remember, the All Asset No Authority Portfolio assumes complete naïveté on the part of the portfolio manager. That’s one extreme of the asset allocation continuum—although few allocators would admit that such an approach might be viable, despite its respectable history.
Momentum Across Asset Classes
In the extreme case where one possesses no other information beyond last year’s total returns, the best single-asset strategy has been to buy the second-best performer (the “Bridesmaid”) and hold it for the next twelve months in hopes that the prior year’s momentum will carry it through. That approach has beaten the S&P 500 by 3.7% annualized over the past 48 years.
Rewarding “Perfect Foresight”
The AANA Portfolio could be viewed as representing one extreme of the asset allocation continuum—in which no knowledge of comparative asset valuations or economic conditions is assumed (or, at least, imparted). At the opposite pole would be the clairvoyant speculator who puts all of his or her eggs into one basket and holds that basket for the entire year.
current issue
