Inside The Stock Market ...trends, cross-currents, and outlook
Novembers To Remember
Big November gains in 2022 and 2023 were clearly kick-off events, while the more speculative backdrop of late 2024 makes the latest November jump look more like a blow-off. Nonetheless, market internals do not reflect a bull that’s ready to top out: The S&P 500 simply has too much companionship at recent highs, including cyclical stocks, financials, and small caps.
“AI” Didn’t Write This, But Could Have
AI might have culled some 2024 stock market dynamics, like Growth over Value and Large Cap over Small Cap from a sample of just a few Green Books from the last dozen years. Maybe the software has already become sentient, as its creators fear.
Speculation Vs. Investing
Statistically (and paradoxically), the consequence of 2024’s huge stock gains has made the market look riskier for long-term investors, but potentially safer for near-term speculators. The larger and broader the upside action, the more challenging the math becomes for the “buy-and-hold” crowd.
Would A Recession Blindside The Market?
Prior to the September 1929 economic downturn, the NYSE Daily Advance/Decline Line had trended sharply lower since early 1928—a sign the market was sniffing out trouble. Today, with the latest highs in the blue chips having been confirmed by the major bellwethers, if a recession materialized in Q1-25, it would likely be the market’s worst failure in history from an economic forecasting perspective.
“Wealth-flationary” Pressures?
Last month, the Fed claimed to be in the “last mile” of the road toward 2% inflation. Naturally, their preferred inflation metric is the one currently nearest that goal: the headline CPI, up 2.6% from a year ago. On the contrary, no other inflation measure suggests the mission is almost accomplished.
The Bull Markets In “P/E” And “E”
Sharply rising projections for EPS are a reason this market doesn’t seem quite as bubbly as its price tag suggests. Barring a sudden collapse, 2024 will be just the third year in which forward earnings estimates and the forward P/E multiple both increase by more than 10%.
Tabulating The Gains
Many factors are apt to limit the bull’s lifespan. A big one is simply the fact that the economy was doing just fine when it began. In the four other times a bull launched without a preceding recession, its gains were solid (+48% to +80%) but never spectacular.
Foreign Stocks: A Half-Off Sale?
Valuations on the MSCI World Ex-USA Index relative to the MSCI USA Index have faded to shockingly low levels. The trailing P/E ratio, P/E on 5-year average EPS, and Price/Cash Flow have sunk to near 50% discounts, while Price/Book and Price/Dividend are even lower.
Trump Bump 2.0?
The markets and the economy in Trump’s first term benefited from both the shock of his election and “initial” conditions. Among the more attractive backdrops of 2016 were a deficit of “just” 3% of GDP, inflation at 2.1%, and restrained investor confidence.
Risky But Not “Toppy”
The cyclical backdrop for stocks looks more precarious than that surrounding Donald Trump’s stunning victory in 2016. That said, there’s no real Technical obstacle to a short-term continuation of the 2024 “Trump Trade.”
Musings On Market Momentum
Last year ended with an extremely rare nine-week winning streak, and the S&P 500 is still charting extraordinary upside momentum more than 10 months later. Historically, after a one-year stock surge of this magnitude (>35%), the U.S. has never declined into recession over the next 12 months.
The Unlikeliest Rate Cut?
Based on leading economic indicators, a case could be made for the Fed to cut rates again. Stocks are telling another story: Based on market momentum and valuation, an impending rate cut might be the least justified one in modern history.
It’s Not If The Curve Matters, But When
November 10th will mark the 2nd anniversary of the initial inversion of the Near Term Forward Spread, the curve most correlated with subsequent growth in real GDP. If a recession fails to materialize, it would be the first “false positive” since 1966.
Smaller Looks Better
For those who believe long-term valuation relationships are still relevant, we recommend moving down the capitalization spectrum. Small Caps’ 5-year estimated forward return is near +11%, while Mid Caps’ is around +8%. The same valuation tool forecasts a mere +3% for Large Caps.
The Warnings Keep Coming
We’d expect monthly jobs numbers to confirm a recession, not forecast one. This cycle, though, employment reports have been warning of a downturn for 2½ years. It would be easy to call them misfires, but red flags keep coming. If a soft landing was in store, the jobs numbers should have improved by now.
Swing... And A Miss!
In October, we published a new election barometer using the DJIA to predict the winner. It failed! Interestingly, the last time this model did not correctly pick the winner was also a year in which the sitting president, who was eligible to run, declined to do so—in 1968.
Relentless, But Risky
The market’s September gain was its fifth in a row and tenth in the last eleven months. If the S&P 500 is up in October, it will mark the first time since 1942 that each of the seasonally “weak” months (May through October) will have seen a gain.
Bubbling Up!
We’ve acknowledged that this rally does not have the bubbly “feel” of either 1999 or 2021, and the absence of giddiness is a reason many pundits think stocks can move much higher. Nonetheless, the stock market is very close to a full-blown bubble: An average of four key valuation metrics places them only one percent away from the historic peak of January 2022—the craziest market top of all time.
The LEI: Historically Out Of Sync
Admittedly, for much of this year, we’ve been wrong in our view that the U.S. economic path was pre-recessionary. We’re in good company: In 2024 the LEI Index has produced the worst three quarters in its 65-year history. Historically, there has been a solid relationship between the LEI and subsequent growth in real GDP; this year’s misses are peculiar.
Job Market Reality Check
Yes, the labor force is growing, but the rate is by no means “rapid.” In fact, its growth rate over the last 12 months of just 0.6% is weaker than any pre-recessionary period since 1956-57.
current issue
